What
Patients Need to Know about Choosing Alternative Medicine
Complementary and alternative medicine, also called CAM, is
enjoying a surge of popularity in the United States. Integrative
medicine is developing as a new form of medical practice.
The standard form of health and medical care practiced in the
United States is conventional medicine, also called
"Western" medicine (its practice began in the Western
Hemisphere) or allopathic medicine. When you go to a doctor who is
an M.D. or a D.O., she will likely diagnose you and treat you based
on the medical knowledge and experience she has gained through
conventional education or practice, using drugs, surgeries or
standard physical therapies.
CAM therapies take a different approach. Most are founded in
Chinese medicine, also called Eastern medicine (emanating from the
Eastern hemisphere). They rely on herbs and other
"natural" substances (we'll explore that word
"natural" below), orienting the human mind or physical
manipulation to achieve health and wellness.
Integrative medicine is a combination approach that takes
complementary, alternative and conventional medicine into
consideration. It's the point at which East meets West for
wellness, and where the combination can allay the disagreement.
What is the Difference Between Complementary and Alternative
Forms of Medicine?
Often, these two terms are used interchangeably. However, there
is a difference.
Alternative therapies are used in place of a conventional medical
approach. If you chose to do yoga instead of going to a physical
therapist, it would be considered an alternative therapy.
Complementary therapies are used together with conventional
therapies. For example, your doctor might suggest you take calcium
for your bones, plus one of the drugs developed to stave off osteoporosis.
Since you are using both approaches, it would be considered
complementary.
What Medical Approaches are Considered to Be Complementary and
Alternative?
You have probably used some forms of CAM without realizing it.
If you put aloe on a cut, for example, or if you take zinc or
ecinacea when a cold gets started, you are using alternative
remedies. Men take saw palmetto for prostate health, and people
with arthritis take glucosamine and chodroitin to help relieve
pain. You may choose foods with antioxidants or omega-3 fatty acids
to stay healthy.
The U.S. government, on its website devoted to Complementary and
Alternative Medicine, breaks down these therapies into five
categories:
- Biologically-Based,
such as herbal supplements, botanicals, animal-derived
products, vitamins, proteins, probiotics and other organic
approaches.
- Energy
Medicine, such as veritable energy like sound, electromagnetic
forces, and light or putative energy fields (also called
biofields) which work to identify a body's own energy field,
also called "chi." Alternative medicine
professionals believe that when these biofields are disturbed,
it causes illness in the body.
Examples of energy medicine are acupuncture, reiki, Qi gong,
homeopathy, healing touch and intercessory prayer in which the
prayers of one person help improve the health of another. These
particular therapies are among the most controversial of the CAM
therapies.
- Manipulative
and Body-Based, such as chiropractic, osteopathic,
reflexology, and therapeutic massage. These therapies rely on
the structures and systems of the body, making adjustments to
them to heal symptoms and medical problems.
- Mind-Body
Medicine, which focuses on the interactions among the brain,
behavior and physical health, such as meditation, yoga,
biofeedback, tai chi, even spirituality.
Even conventional medicine has long understood the relationship
between the mind and the body. Mental health and physical health
are intertwined, and this type of approach is being used more and
more for pain control, cancer management, and is being explored to
learn more about its immunity response.
- Whole
Medical Systems that have evolved totally separately from what
we consider to be conventional medicine in the United States.
These systems have names like naturopathy, homeopathy,
traditional Chinese medicine, Eastern medicine and Ayurvedic
medicine. You will see some of these names already mentioned
in the categories above. The distinction here is in the way
they developed rather than the therapy itself.
What is Integrative Medicine?
For those practitioners and patients who want to consider both
conventional and CAM medicine in their medical decision-making, the
integrative model makes sense.
Integrative medicine is the combination of the two. It takes the
best practices of both worlds, reviews the evidence for treating
whatever the patient's medical problem is, and combines them to
benefit the patient. An integrative doctor will choose from either
conventional medicine, or CAM, or will choose them together.
For example, there is evidence that teaching breast cancer patients
to meditate, a complementary treatment, in combination with
chemotherapy, a conventional treatment, improves their outcomes. It
helps reduce stress, improve mood, improve their quality of sleep
and reduce their fatigue. This is both complementary and
integrative.
Are CAM Remedies Really "Natural"?
Some are. Some are not. Sometimes herbs and other plant
substances are combined with non-natural additives to make an
alternative supplement.
You'll find many claims that supplements are "natural."
You are supposed to draw the conclusion that "natural"
equates to safe -- and that is not always true. Not all natural
substances are safe (think arsenic or toxic plants), which also
contributes to the controversy behind complementary and alternative
therapies.
Thinking About CAM for Yourself?
If you are interested in pursuing complementary or alternative
therapies, and just as you should for any therapy you and your
doctor decide to choose, be sure to:
- Understand
the controversies, then...
- Do your
research, including...
- Review of
the evidence.
- Then talk to
your doctor. If your doctor is unwilling to help you integrate
CAM treatment, then...
- You may need
to change doctors.
|